Property

In General

Building the Cathedral as Sanctuary
Recognizing Action as the Basis of Property

by Justin Michael Altman
"By developing a theory of property based on purposeful action, a simple construction of the qualities of property emerge and coercive action is quickly shown to be the equivalent of making a property claim in the will of another."

Cause No Conflict
by Kris Borer
"The objects commonly referred to as property are simply means of an individual’s proper action."

Confiscation and the Homestead Principle
by Murray N. Rothbard

The Economics of Property Rights
by Svetozar Pejović

Freedom and Property: Where They Conflict
by Frank van Dun
"Suppose a person complains about being isolated from the rest of the world by his neighbors' noninvasive actions and presents his case to a judge. Which judge is closer to the libertarian spirit and more likely to contribute to conditions of peaceful coexistence? One who dismisses the complaint because the neighbors do not trespass on the property of the complainant, or one who is willing to hear the complaint and, if it turns out to be justified, willing to decide that the neighbors are under an obligation to grant a right of way to the complainant?"

"Human Rights" as Property Rights
by Murray N. Rothbard
"Liberals generally wish to preserve the concept of “rights” for such “human” rights as freedom of speech, while denying the concept to private property. And yet, on the contrary the concept of “rights” only makes sense as property rights. For not only are there no human rights which are not also property rights, but the former rights lose their absoluteness and clarity and become fuzzy and vulnerable when property rights are not used as the standard."

John Locke’s Theory of Property: Problems of Interpretation
by Karen I. Vaughn
"In the middle part of the twentieth century, the whole constitutional-limited government-liberal enterprise has been called into question, and part of the questioning process has been a renewed interest in the political philosophy of John Locke. Heralding the new interest in Locke were three studies that challenged Locke’s credentials as a classical liberal and all based their challenge on a reading of Locke’s theory of property. The works of Willmoore Kendall, Leo Strauss, and C.B. MacPherson all argued that Locke was not at all what he was supposed to be, and they thereby opened up a new investigation of the meaning and importance of Locke’s theory of property in his political thought."

Native Americans and Property Rights
by Leonard P. Liggio

The Natural and Artificial Right of Property Contrasted
by Thomas Hodgskin
"Legislation, according to my view, was originally founded in conquest, and it has ever since been continued in utter ignorance of its results. As was the primitive act, so are all its consequences hostile to the course of nature. As long as mankind obey principles flowing from that primitive aggression, so long will they be tormented by open theft and secret fraud, which tending to destroy confidence, and making each man act as much as possible for himself, instead of all mutually exchanging their services, check division of labour far more even than restrictions on trade. As long as political society is based on mutual oppression and plunder, so long shall we all suffer from that profligate scorn of natural right, which, dictating the conduct of those in high places, corrupts others by its example; so long also shall we be tormented by courts of law, and customs, and excise duties, and visits from the taxgatherer; which prevent every man from knowing what accurately belongs to himself, and making him hold even food, drink, and clothing, by the insecure tenor of the tax-inflictor's conscience, and the lawyer's mystic interpretation of almost incomprehensible decrees, convert our naturally happy existence into a long scene of contention, uncertainty, and dread."

On Property and Exploitation
by Hans-Hermann Hoppe and Walter Block

Owning the Unownable
March 1995
by Paul Georgia
"Critics of free market environmentalism advance three major arguments. The first is that it is impossible to assign property rights to—or “fence”—the atmosphere, groundwater, or the oceans."

The Primacy of Property in a Liberal Constitutional Order: Lessons for China
by James A. Dorn
"The key to a successful future for China is the adoption of a constitution that protects persons and property against arbitrary government power and lays a framework for freedom under the rule of law. Just as Adam Smith articulated the principles of liberalism in the West, so the wisdom of Lao Tzu can play a similar role in China’s transition from market socialism to 'market Taoism.'”

Private Property
by Ludwig von Mises
"Private ownership of the means of production is the fundamental institution of the market economy. It is the institution the presence of which characterizes the market economy as such. Where it is absent, there is no question of a market economy."

Property
by Louis-François-Michel-Raymond Wolowski and Pierre Émile Levasseur
"It is, then, to the human being, the creator of all wealth, that we must come back; it is upon liberty that it is expedient to base the principle of property, and if any one would know the sign by which it is to be recognized, we will answer that it is by labor that man impresses his personality upon matter."

Property and Freedom by Richard Pipes
reviewed by Peter Mentzel
"Relying primarily on the histories of England and Russia, Pipes makes a compelling argument that freedom and private property are intimately linked."

Property and its Enemies, Part I: "Design Faults" in Locke's Theory of Property Taint Ownership with Guilt, Part II: Is Ownership a Myth?, Part III: How to Get a Free Lunch? Just Apply for It.
by Anthony de Jasay
"He begins with an analysis of the 17th century English political philosopher, John Locke, whose ideas on property as a natural right of mankind was one of the guiding principles of the American Revolution. But as Jasay notes, paradoxically, Locke's theory of property contains a "proviso" which has been seized upon by many critics in order to undermine the very idea of a natural right to private property. . . .
In this article Jasay takes on a number of philosophers who belong to what he calls the "ownership is a myth" school: J. Christman, L. Murphy and T. Nagel, and J. Waldron. These philosophers argue that property "rights" are just part of a "legal convention" and must be evaluated by "society" to determine whether they conform to notions of "social" and not individual justice. . . .
Jasay takes issue with a new group of "enemies of property", namely the contributors to a collection of essays entitled What Is Wrong With A Free Lunch? (2001) in which the idea of a government guaranteed minimum income for all is advocated." -- David Hart

Property Rights: Cooperation, Conflict, and Law edited by Terry L. Anderson and Fred S. McChesny
reviewed by James W. Ely Jr.
"Anderson and McChesney’s fine volume should help to enlighten property scholars about the economic contours of property rights. One hopes that it will prompt other scholars to revisit prevalent assumptions about the origins and nature of private property."

Property Rights Must Evolve with Changing Values
March 05, 2003
by John A. Baden, Ph.D.
"Clear and enforceable property rights subject to the rule of law, not political influence, are essential to environmental protection and justice. Property rights can protect the individual from powerful interests. Only if these rights are clear, well defined, enforceable, and transferable do they foster peace and justice. The intractable problems involving migratory fish and wildlife demonstrate the burdens imposed by unclear or contested rights."

Property: The Great Problem Solver
by Morris and Linda Tannehill
"Most social problems which perplex national leaders could be solved fairly simply by an increase in the amount and type of property owned. This would entail the equally important, general recognition that ownership is and must be total, rather than merely a governmental permission to possess and/or manage property so long as certain legal rules are complied with and "rent" in the form of property taxes is paid."

The Right of Property
1897
by Herbert Spencer
"There are three ways in which, under savage, semicivilized, and civilized conditions, men's several rights of property may be established with due regard to the equal rights of all other men."

The Separation of Property and the State
by Anthony Gregory
"Now, to see if a left-anarchist is really an anarchist, it comes down to this: if, in an anarchist society, businesses emerged, people decided to trade, including their labor, and it became clear that these markets, however hierarchical, existed not because of state enforcement but because of the voluntarily pursued preference of the individuals involved – regardless of how exploited you considered the workers to be and regardless of the attractive voluntary communalism that would also supposedly emerge – would you advocate the initiation force to stop it? If so, you are not an anarchist, any more than an atheist who advocates the forced abolition of religion is an anarchist. To see if an “anarcho-capitalist” is really an anarchist, a similar test can be used: would you use a state to create capitalism where none before existed? If so, you are not an anarchist, any more than a theist who advocates theocracy."

The Social Nature of Ownership
by Spencer MacCallum

Succinct Criticism of Utilitarianism and Libertarian Creationism
September 7, 2010
by Stephan Kinsella
"Lockean homesteading works simply because by transforming and using an unowned resource first you establish a better claim to it; there is no need in this argument to assume that labor is “owned”. And thus, there is no basis for the creationist view that if you labor to make an information pattern that you own that pattern. Labor only serves as part of homesteading in that it is just the way human action transforms and thus emborders a previously-unowned scarce resource."

What Exactly Is Freedom?
by David MacGregor
"Next time you read or hear of any contentious issue, try applying the question, "Whose property is involved here?", and you'll be surprised how much clarity it brings to bear."

Who owns what?
by Roy Halliday
Chapter 5 of Enforceable Rights: A Libertarian Theory of Justice.

Airwaves

Whose Airwaves Are They?
July 2004
by Sheldon Richman
"With good reason people worry about what they and their children might be exposed to on radio and television, and I don’t mean to minimize that concern. But I do mean to say that collective—that is, government—ownership is an illegitimate solution in a free society."

Bodies

Argumentation and Self-Ownership
by Hans-Hermann Hoppe
"Nobody could argue in favor of a property system defining borders of property in subjective, evaluative terms because simply to be able to say so presupposes that, contrary to what theory says, one must in fact be a physically independent unit saying it."

How We Come to Own Ourselves
by N. Stephan Kinsella
"The primary social evil of our time is lack of respect for self-ownership rights. It is what underlies private crime as well as institutionalized crime perpetrated by the state."

I Own My Body, NOT The Government. So Why The Hell Do THey Think They have The Right To Tell Me What I Do With It??
by Neale Osborn
"Who owns your body? I mean the physical shell your mind inhabits, and also the products MADE by that body/mind combo??"

Moral or Immoral Government
December 7, 2010
by Walter E. Williams
"My initial assumption is that we each own ourselves. I am my private property and you are yours. If we accept the notion that people own themselves, then it's easy to discover what forms of conduct are moral and immoral. Immoral acts are those that violate self-ownership. Murder, rape, assault and slavery are immoral because those acts violate private property. So is theft, broadly defined as taking the rightful property of one person and giving it to another."

The Production and Exchange of Used Body Parts
1971
by Simon Rottenberg
"This paper will discuss the market, as an alternative to a system of voluntary donation, as an instrument for bringing forth a supply of organs and securing their storage and their appropriate distribution in space and time."

Self-Ownership
by Robert LeFevre
"Each person owns himself and all of his functions, including those of sex, digestion, cognition, and so on. Among the greatest satisfactions available to human beings are those which recognize other persons as equals in the property ownership of self. Although a man may wish an exclusive association with a particular friend, and while it may be possible to contract for such an exclusive relationship, the fact remains that each party to any association always remains the owner of himself."

Who Owns the Dead?
by Adam Young
"From time to time, the injustice of the ban on buying and selling organs is raised in libertarian circles. What I want to do is raise and attempt to “defend the indefensible” by exploring the larger question: Can you own the recently dead? In other words, under the ideal libertarian conditions of unobstructed self-ownership, could you inherit, or purchase and sell property titles to, a corpse?"

Land

"Beyond the Wit of Man to Foresee": Voluntaryism and Land Use Controls
by Carl Watner
"The most effective type of voluntary zoning is the result of private covenants, market pricing, and competition. The social potential inherent in the development of property and real estate under voluntaryism is beyond the wit of man to foresee."

The Case Against Geoism
by Jan Narveson
"The idea that we all have an equal right to the land is amazingly arbitrary, and contrary to all human experience while it's at it. It's arbitrary in that it has no basis. The fact that we don't make the land is irrelevant, as already seen: we don't make the natural part of anything we have or own, no matter whether we have "made" it or not. But the point is, it doesn't matter. For things are just things: they do not come with labels saying that they "belong" to some people or that some people, somehow, have a "claim" on them, nor in turn that everybody has a claim on them, equal or otherwise."

Earning Happiness Through Homesteading Unowned Land: a comment on 'Buying Misery with Federal Land' by Richard Stroup
by Walter Block

The Economics and Ethics of Land Reform: A Critique of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace's "Toward a Better Distribution of Land: The Challenge of Agrarian Reform"
by Walter Block and Guillermo Yeatts

The Greatest Privatization Ever
June 2004
by Robert Higgs
"In the Land Ordinance of 1785 and the Northwest Ordinance of 1787, Congress spelled out how the public domain would be transferred to private owners and divided into new states. These laws had the greatest importance in determining how successfully the country would develop."

Man and Matter: How the Former Gains Ownership of the Latter
by Per Bylund
"This study seeks to investigate the nature of ownership of land, and how the right to its control and use can be inferred from self-ownership as a premise."

Our Languishing Public Lands
The Economic and Environmental Benefits of Decentralization

February 1, 2012
Robert H. Nelson
"The solution is to be found in first identifying those areas of the public lands which are capable of yielding a national consensus as to their management purpose—likely to be the most environmentally attractive parts of the public lands, such as wilderness areas. The operative goals on the remaining, less nationally significant lands should be decentralization and privatization. Where the circumstances of the lands allow for a workable system of private property rights (both the main benefits and the main costs can be assigned to the same private party), the lands should be privatized (or transferred to long-term private leases). Where the circumstances of the land involve more beneficiaries and larger transaction costs of group decision making, some new collective governing instruments will be required. In some cases, private collective ownerships—the rise of private community associations in recent years may offer a model—may be feasible. Perhaps more often, the lands will have to remain in the public sector, but their management should be decentralized to new lower-level units of governance where broad agreement on goals is more likely and where effective management purposes and methods can thus more easily win acceptance. In the public sector, the newly decentralized units of land governance might be a state, a county, a municipality, or limited segments of such. In some cases a brand new government unit might be created specifically for public land purposes such as a form of public corporation."

Ownership of Land
by Robert LeFevre
"To maximize human well-being and to minimize disputes, private ownership and management of land and all appurtenances to land should be encouraged. Further, the land should be untaxed. The owner should own totally, once all encumbrances have been removed."

Sowing and Reaping Devastation in Haiti: The property-rights vacuum explains a lot.
February 15, 2010
by T. Norman Van Cott
"My point is that Haitian land stripped of its trees and Haitian land covered with earthquake debris trace to a common cause. That cause is the dysfunctional state of Haitian private property rights. Dysfunctional is charitable — a property-rights vacuum is more apt. The vacuum promotes economic myopia among Haitians. Future benefits — from preserving trees to constructing longer-lived buildings — figure less importantly in economic calculations when the benefits’ recipients are uncertain."

Spencerian Ethics and Land
by Benjamin R. Tucker
"In Liberty's view, the occupancy-and-use theory of land tenure is as inconsistent with Spencerian ethics as is the existing system of land tenure. Spencerian ethics requires the believers therein to adopt some method, be it Communism, or Land Nationalization, or the Single Tax, of giving to all men equal use of the entire earth. Of course, no method can possibly accomplish that result; but that only shows the absurdity of the Spencerian ethics."

This Land Is Mine
by Roderick Long
"Our relation to the products of our labour is simply an extension of our relation to our bodies; indeed, our bodies themselves are to a large extent the product of our labour (though the particles composing them are not), just as cultivated land is the product of our labour (though again the particles composing it are not)."

When Is a Land Title Criminal?
by Murray N. Rothbard
"A particularly important application of our theory of property titles is the case of landed property. For one thing, land is a fixed quotal portion of the earth, and therefore the ground land endures virtually permanently. Historical investigation of land titles therefore would have to go back much further than for other more perishable goods. However, this is by no means a critical problem, for, as we have seen, where the victims are lost in antiquity, the land properly belongs to any non-criminals who are in current possession."

Private Property

Coase and Demsetz on Private Property Rights
by Walter Block

The Economics and Ethics of Private Property: Studies in Political Economy and Philosophy by Hans-Hermann Hoppe
reviewed by N. Stephan Kinsella
November 1994
"The Economics and Ethics of Private Property contains cutting-edge economic theories and breakthroughs in epistemology and individual rights theories."

Enforcement of Private Property Rights in Primitive Societies: Law without Government
by Bruce L. Benson

Human Rights are Property Rights
April 1st, 1959
by Murray Rothbard
"Much is heard these days of the distinction between human rights and property rights, and many who claim to champion the one turn with scorn upon any de­fender of the other. They fail to see that property rights, far from being in conflict, are in fact the most basic of all human rights."

The Justification of Private Property by First-Comers
by Jan Narveson
"Private property, acquirable by sheer finding and other sorts of industry, stands in the field head and shoulders above all rival theories."

On Airports and Individual Rights
by Tibor R. Machan
"Some people will say that stringent protection of rights would lead to small airports, at best, and many constraints on construction. Of course—but what’s so wrong with that?"

A Positive Account of Property Rights
by David Friedman
"The central project of this essay has been to give an account of rights, especially property rights, that is both amoral and alegal -- an account that would explain the sort of behavior we associate with rights even in a world lacking law, law enforcement, and feelings of moral obligation."

The Primacy of Property Rights and the American Founding
February 1998
by David Upham
"Whatever may be the merits of the extension of the suffrage only to property owners, this much is clear: the Founders’ opinions in this regard manifest clearly that they did not hold property rights in low esteem. As we have seen, they viewed the right to property to be not only as important as other human rights, but in some respects as the most important human right. Economic freedom was a most important freedom, and its vulnerability to factional hostility required that it be afforded extensive constitutional guarantees. Paradoxically, this most vulnerable of freedoms was also understood to be the best practical guarantee of the other freedoms; for the private ownership of property provided not only real power to the citizens, it also instilled in them that virtue of self-reliance and self-governance essential to a politically self-governing people."

Private Property
by Ludwig von Mises
"Private ownership of the means of production is the fundamental institution of the market economy. It is the institution the presence of which characterizes the market economy as such. Where it is absent, there is no question of a market economy."

Private Property and Its Critics
by Ludwig von Mises
"What is always criticized in the capitalist system is the fact that the owners of the means of production occupy a preferential position. They can live without working. If one views the social order from an individualistic standpoint, one must see in this a serious shortcoming of capitalism. Why should one man be better off than another? But whoever considers things, not from the standpoint of individual persons, but from that of the whole social order, will find that the owners of property can preserve their agreeable position solely on condition that they perform a service indispensable for society. The capitalist can keep his favored position only by shifting the means of production to the application most important for society. If he does not do this—if he invests his wealth unwisely—he will suffer losses, and if he does not correct his mistake in time, he will soon be ruthlessly ousted from his preferential position. He will cease to be a capitalist, and others who are better qualified for it will take his place. In a capitalist society, the deployment of the means of production is always in the hands of those best fitted for it; and whether they want to or not, they must constantly take care to employ the means of production in such a way that they yield the greatest output."

Private property - a prerequisite for classical capitalism
by Svetozar Pejović

Private Property or Possession: A Synthesis
"A use-right theory might be the most equal and efficient way of using natural resources, with rights but without property."

Property codes violation of rights
February 3, 2011
by Kent McManigal
"I understand that some people get offended when a neighbor has an unkempt lawn or a junky car in their yard. Yet, what another person does with their own property, even to the point of destroying it, is no one else's business as long as no one else or their property is being harmed -- and being offended doesn't qualify as harm."

Property and Liberty

Libertarianism and Property Rights
by Jan Narveson
"The title of this paper might well have been, not just Libertarianism and Property Rights but indeed, Libertarianism = Property Rights."

Libertarianism and Property Rights
by Walter Block

Liberty, Property, and Crime
November 2001
by Jim Peron
"All the problems of social order that the “broken window” policy is meant to fix are direct results of the lack of private property."

Property and Freedom
1971
by Alberto Benegas Lynch
"Although liberty is the essential element of the advance of civilization, private property is its prerequisite and its principal component. We cannot imagine individual freedom without private property. To acquire and possess private property and its free disposal, is indispensable for the free creative activity of individuals."

Property and Freedom: The Inseparable Connection
by Dr. Richard Pipes
reviewed by Yun N. Maltsev
September 2000
"Private property is always closely connected with law, which explains Russia’s failure to develop a functional judiciary system. In case of any disagreement or contract violation, business resorts to arbitration or the mafia, since the courts will not enforce private contracts."

Property and Liberty
September 2000
by James Bovard
"It is important to have freedom to buy and sell, to invest, to innovate, to choose one’s risks and reap one’s profits—but it is not enough. It is also vital that police not be able to break people’s heads, or entrap them on bogus charges, or intercept their e-mail at a whim, or target them because of their race, ethnicity, or political ideas. Unfortunately, some advocates of economic freedom seem nonchalant about practically any use of government power that does not directly interfere with profit-making."

Property and Exchange
by Murray Rothbard
"The central core of the libertarian creed, then, is to establish the absolute right to private property of every man: first, in his own body, and second, in the previously unused natural resources which he first transforms by his labor. These two axioms, the right of self-ownership and the right to "homestead," establish the complete set of principles of the libertarian system. The entire libertarian doctrine then becomes the spinning out and the application of all the implications of this central doctrine."

Property: Key to Self-Determination
by Sheldon Richman
December 1997
"If the freedom philosophy is to prevail, advocates of private property will need to make it clear that without full protection of property rights we are all poorer—and not just in the economic sense."

Property Protects
September 2005
by Sheldon Richman
"If liberty is to be won, its defenders must emphasize that property especially protects the most vulnerable against government impositions."

The Proprietary Theory of Justice in the Libertarian Tradition
by Carl Watner

A Theory of Property Rights for a Free Nation
by Roy Halliday
The homestead principle is the source of property rights and is necessary for the establishment of a free nation.

Van Dun on Freedom and Property: A Critique
by Walter Block

What Exactly Is Freedom?
by David MacGregor
"Next time you read or hear of any contentious issue, try applying the question, "Whose property is involved here?", and you'll be surprised how much clarity it brings to bear."

Property and Morality

In Defense of Property Rights and Capitalism
June 1993
by Tibor R. Machan
"When the most prominent advocates of the free market are economists, it appears that nothing other than efficiency matters about the marketplace. But, in fact, there are certain normative or ethical features of the free society that an economic analysis of free markets leaves unmentioned. This would not be a problem if economists were not the virtually exclusive defenders of the free market. But the market rests on institutions and ideas that are ethical in nature."

The Economics and Ethics of Private Property: Studies in Political Economy and Philosophy by Hans-Hermann Hoppe
reviewed by Robert W. McGee

The Economics and Ethics of Private Property: Studies in Political Economy and Philosophy by Hans-Hermann Hoppe
reviewed by Walter Block

In Praise of Private Property and a Peaceful World Order
by Michael S. Rozeff
"Private property rights lessen disputes by making ownership well-defined. Moreover, those who exchange property have an incentive to coordinate rules of justice across broad regions in order to lower the costs of contract disputes."

Justice and Property Rights: The Failure of Utilitarianism
by Murray N. Rothbard
"In short, for an economist to say that X and Y should be free to trade Good A for Good B unmolested by third parties, he must also say that X legitimately and properly owns Good A and that Y legitimately owns Good B. But this means that the free-market economist must have some sort of theory of justice in property rights; he can scarcely say that X properly owns Good A without asserting some sort of theory of justice on behalf of such ownership."

King Charles Ax: Property Rights, Human Freedom, and The Quality of Life
May 1994
by John Robson
"There is no doubt at this point in history that violations of property rights do not achieve their goals, and indeed East Germany was not a prosperous place. But money cannot buy happiness, and what was really wrong with the GDR, as Herr Klottschen rightly stated, was that people’s dreams and ideals were destroyed. Even if the GDR had enjoyed greater material wealth than, say, eighteenth-century England, the latter would have been a better place to live.
So it is wrong, even preposterous, to call property rights materialistic. They are the most basic human right. They are the only human right. They are what makes life worth living."

The Moral Foundations of Property Rights
November 1986
by Brian Summers
"What do the arguments for private ownership say about the justice of current property holdings? Do they endorse the status quo? Or do they call for a massive transfer (“redistribution”) of property rights?"

No Rights without Property Rights
October 1956
by Frank Chodorov
"And so, it is sheer verbalism to speak of any kind of freedom existing where the right of property is not respected, or to separate this right from any other. We can therefore dismiss any hope that under communism—the essential feature of which is the abolition of private property—there can be any relaxation of personal controls and repressions. Stalinite brutality may be replaced by more subtle methods, like permitting the worker to starve if he does not wish to work in the mines; but freedom is out of the question."

On the Ultimate Justification of the Ethics of Private Property
by Hans-Hermann Hoppe

Property and Criminality
by Murray N. Rothbard
"A criminal is anyone who initiates violence against another man and his property: anyone who uses the coercive “political means” for the acquisition of goods and services."

Property and Exploitation
by Hans-Hermann Hoppe and Walter Block

Property and the Moral Life
February 1998
by Jason Baldwin
"The sphere of sovereignty that property provides is a sphere necessary to the moral autonomy of the person. Property forms a cushion of independence for each person from the moral intrusiveness of other individuals and the state."

Private Property and Ethics
by Ludwig von Mises
"In seeking to demonstrate the social function and necessity of private ownership of the means of production and of the concomitant inequality in the distribution of income and wealth, we are at the same time providing proof of the moral justification for private property and for the capitalist social order based upon it."

Private Property, Freedom and the West
by James Gwartney

Rothbardian Ethics
by Hans-Hermann Hoppe
"As simple as the solution to the problem of social order is and as much as people in their daily lives intuitively recognize and act according to the ethics of private property just explained, this simple and undemanding solution implies some surprisingly radical conclusions. For, apart from ruling out as unjustified all activities such as murder, homicide, rape, trespass, robbery, burglary, theft, and fraud, the ethics of private property is also incompatible with the existence of a state defined as an agency that possesses a compulsory territorial monopoly of ultimate decision-making (jurisdiction) and/or the right to tax."

The Source of Rights
November 1984
by Frank Chodorov
"Whatever else socialism is, or is claimed to be, its first tenet is the denial of private property. All brands of socialism, and there are many, are agreed that property rights must be vested in the political establishment. None of the schemes identified with this ideology, such as the nationalization of industry, or socialized medicine, or the abolition of free choice, or the planned economy, can become operative if the individual’s claim to his property is recognized by the government."

The Undeniable Morality of Capitalism
by N. Stephan Kinsella
A review essay of The Economics and Ethics of Private Property: Studies in Political Economy and Philosophy by Hans-Hermann Hoppe.

Property and Prosperity

Defined and secure property rights will reduce conflict in Africa
September 27, 2005
by Karol Boudreaux
"Across Africa resource conflict is behind much of the violence, death, and destruction that plague the continent. The problem involves herders and farmers in the dry Sahel. It involves mineral wealth in Nigeria and Angola. Even in South Africa, some of problems of violence associated with the taxi industry can be attributed to fighting over lucrative routes: another type of resource. Resolving resource conflicts is essential to bring peace to Africa, but it will require many African governments to do something they have not, so far at least, been very good at: they must create systems of clearly defined, defendable and secure property rights that are accessible and affordable for all their citizens."

Help the Third World -- Protect Property Rights
February 23, 2010
by Doug Bandow
"Much goes into the process of economic development. One of the most important factors is the protection of property rights, both physical and intellectual. Today the Property Rights Alliance (PRA) released its latest annual International Property Rights Index (IPRI), written by Victoria Strokova, with contributions from many others. Countries which do the most to strengthen property rights have the best economic results."

Property and Prosperity: The Vital Link
January 2004
by Tibor R. Machan
"It doesn’t seem to occur to these critics of liberty that without the right to private property it is not possible to choose to pursue those allegedly higher goals. A slave or serf or hostage isn’t at liberty to elect to do whatever is deemed to be his duty."

Why the Poor Need Property Rights
October 2002
by Jim Peron
"Street traders represent the beginning of what de Soto calls "a long march" to capitalism. When hampered and harassed by government, the natural evolution of property rights is prevented. The result is decline and decay. But when, instead of controlling, government acts as a protector of property rights, then street trading is the first step toward prosperity."

Water

Concerning Water
March 1956
by Murray N. Rothbard
This letter is a response to The Ownership And Control Of Water.
"If a man is entitled to the product he creates, he also is entitled to the nature-given land that he first finds and brings into productivity. In other words, land including water, mines, and the like—in an unused, primitive state is economically unowned and worthless and therefore should be legally unowned. It should be owned legally by that person who first makes use of it. This is a principle which we might call 'first ownership to first user.'”

Environmental Takings of Private Water Rights: the Case for Full Water Privatization
by Roy Whitehead and Walter Block

The Ownership And Control Of Water
November 1955
by de Tocqueville
"My primary purpose in writing this letter is to solicit ideas from you or members of your staff on a problem which is currently engaging my interest and part of my time. I am endeavoring to appraise legal systems by which water resources are allocated. The primary criterion in making this appraisal is whether or not these systems are conducive to efficient utilization of water resources. My first impression is that a system which places water resources in private hands and relies on consumer choice and free competition will be most conducive to efficient utilization of such resources." Murray Rothbard responded to this letter. See Concerning Water.

Who Owns Water?
March 1956
by Murray N. Rothbard
"It is immediately clear that the route to justice lies along the appropriation rather than the riparian path. Why riparian? What claim does a landowner have to any part of a stream just because his land adjoins the stream? No moral claim whatever. His riparian claim is not based on his having made use of the water; in fact, his only purpose seems to be to block anyone else from using the water, and the result is criminal waste of rivers and streams."

Anti-Property

Communal Property

Common Property in Free Market Anarchism: A Missing Link
by Carlton Hobbs
"Perhaps this essay will engage a more rigorous thinker than myself to complete the all-encompassing systems of Rothbard and Mises regarding this subject. This is one of very few areas to my knowledge of the nature and workings of a free society that our movement has not deconstructed and thoroughly analyzed."

Communal vs. Private Property Rights
February 1988
by James D. Gwartney and Richard L. Stroup
"The following examples, ranging from the sixteenth century to the present day, and from cultures as diverse as the American Indians and Communist Russia, illustrate the value of private property rights and the difficulties posed by communal property."

A Plea for Public Property
by Roderick T. Long
Natural rights supports public property as well as private property.

Public Goods Fallacies: False Justifications for Government
by Francois-Rene Rideau
This article exposes economic and moral fallacies used to justify state intervention in the market.

The World's Biggest Oxymoron
by Jim Davies
"It permeates our society . . . alas. It's 'public property.'"

Theft

Not Yours to Give
by Colonel David Crockett
"The famous American hero Davy Crokett, who died at the Alamo, colorfully articulates why government has neither the right nor the wisdom to take what others have produced and redistribute it to a politically privileged few in the name of charity."

Zoning

How Zoning Rules Would Work in a Free Society
June 17, 2009
by Ben O'Neill
"Contrary to the alleged necessity of zoning laws, there is ample scope for noncoercive solutions to zoning issues in the context of a free society of private-property ownership and nonaggression. In particular, private ownership of property allows for restrictive covenants to be agreed between the property owner and another party so that the allowable uses of land are limited according to the wishes of the parties. It follows that property owners within a given neighborhood may contractually agree to impose restrictions on themselves with respect to the allowable developments on their land or the allowable uses of their property."

Just Zone Out
by John Robson
"Jane Jacobs was a legend for a reason - she was on to something."

Zoning Laws Destroy Communities
April 30, 2010
by Troy Camplin
"Zoning laws are a violation of property rights. They destroy the sense of community in neighborhoods, increase crime, increase traffic congestion, contribute to urban and suburban air pollution, contribute to poverty, contribute to reliance in government — and, thus, reduce self-reliance — and contribute to the ruin of our schools."

Back to the list of topics

This page was last updated on August 25, 2012.